ICE responds to lawsuit, releases detainees in the region

German Fuentes and “Mr. Gonzalez” are both free, as of Monday. The two men had been held at the Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention center in Farmville, despite the fact both won their immigration cases more than three months ago. But the sudden shift from ICE came as the result of a lawsuit filed earlier this month by a combination of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Virginia, the Capital Area Immigrants’ Rights Coalition (CAIR) and the National Immigration Project (NIP).

“Holding our clients in detention for no good reason violated the Constitution, immigration law and ICE’s own policy,” said Sophia Gregg. She serves as Immigrants’ Rights Attorney for the ACLU of Virginia. “We’re pleased that ICE recognized it had no right to continue to hold our clients, but it’s concerning that the ICE Washington Field Office has given no indication that it will rectify what has become a pattern of holding non-citizens for months after they won their cases.”

What is the ICE case based on? 

The case involves one question. Is it legal for ICE to continue to detain someone, regardless of the result of their court case? That’s what the ACLU alleges is happening now and has been for some time. The argument is that even if someone wins their immigration case, ICE has been refusing to release them immediately.

In March 2023, an immigration judge ruled that Fuentes would likely face persecution or torture if he was sent home to El Salvador. One month later, the judge found the same for a man only identified as “Mr. Gonzalez” if he returned to Honduras.

As a result, all three men, in their respective cases, fell under specific guidelines. If a judge rules in your favor during a case like this, they can do so in two ways. First, they can grant you “withholding of removal” protection. That is what happened with the man named “Mr. Gonzalez” in the lawsuit.

Withholding of removal is similar to asylum. According to the American Immigration Council (AIC), a person under a “withholding of removal” order is protected from being deported to their home country, and receives the right to remain in the United States and work legally. But there is a catch. “An immigration judge (still) enters a deportation order and then tells the government they cannot execute that order,” AIC officials said in a statement on their website. While the person is protected from being deported to their own country, “the government is still allowed to deport that person to a different country, if the other country agrees to accept them,” the council explains.

In this case, that’s what the ACLU claims happened to “Mr. Gonzalez”. He was held in custody while immigration officials tried to find another country that was willing to take him. But at what point should that process end? The ruling was in April and “Mr. Gonzalez” just now left detention this week.

The second way 

Now as mentioned before, there’s a second way the judge can rule in a case like this. He or she can grant deferral of removal. That’s what happened to Germano Fuentes in Farmville.

This means a judge has put in a deportation order, but tells the government not to enforce it right now. Now the American Immigration Council says a judge issues this, rather than the withholding mentioned above, to people who have a criminal record or could be considered some type of security risk due to other reasons determined by the court.

Basically, yes, they’ve proven returning home would be dangerous. But the judge has some concerns about their stay here.

It’s not quite the same as withholding. Anyone granted deferred removal can be held in detention and aren’t automatically given employment authorization. They can be released and given that approval, however, by order of the regional ICE director. While we haven’t seen any employment authorization granted for Fuentes, he has been released.

What happens next?

ACLU officials said while this is a step in the right direction, they plan to keep filing petitions.

“It shouldn’t take a federal lawsuit to get ICE to comply with its own policies,” Gregg said. “We’ll continue to bring habeas petitions against the ICE Washington Field Office for its ongoing violations until the agency honors immigrants’ constitutional rights and releases them to their families and communities.”

The Gazette reached out to ICE officials, but had no response by presstime.

SportsPlus

Local

CODI Alert now set up for law enforcement in Charlotte County

Education

‘Cell phone-free’ education bill filed. How will it affect Charlotte?

High School

Randolph-Henry golf team secures district tournament win

Columns

From the Editor’s Desk: You’d be surprised how much that helps

Local

Gary Walker sentence handed down. Judge gives specific deadline

Columns

Mike Wilson: I deeply sympathize with Rodney Dangerfield

Community Calendar

Five County Fair returns: Here’s a look at this year’s schedule

Local

Charlotte County Crime: What does the state report say?

Local

Speed study details issues around two Charlotte County schools

Business

Amish construction must meet state code, Charlotte officials say

Local

Madeline’s House set to reopen later this month, with new owners

High School

Randolph-Henry golf team secures regular season district title

Education

Randolph-Henry High students, staff reflect on 9-11 attacks

Business

Internet outages caused by hunters, Firefly Fiber officials warn

Business

Charlotte County supervisors asked to consider amending budget

Local

Jordaine Penick wins HEAT Hornets title, sets new goal

Lifestyle Main

Charlotte County FFA Alumni celebrate with annual dinner

Columns

Mike Wilson: Need help hunting? It’s a how-to guide to gearing up

High School

Football Preview: Fully healthy, Statesmen ready to get to work

Local

Charlotte County Library system gets some help from the Assembly

Local

Jordaine Penick takes aim at history this coming Saturday

Education

Randolph-Henry High ‘Noted Statesmen’ selected for August

Church & Community

Gazette Church and Community Calendar: week of Aug. 28

Education

Fuqua rolls out construction plans, will build new Upper School